AJTS - African Journal of Traumatic Stress
A publication of African Psycare Research Organisation In Collaboration with Makerere University College of Health Science.
TRAUMA AND POST-TRAUMATIC STRESS DISORDER: APPROACHES TO TREATMENT FOR VICTIMS IN POST-CONFLICT COMMUNITIES IN NORTHERN UGANDA
AUTHOR: James Okello
Mental Health Department, Faculty of Medicine, Gulu University, Gulu, Uganda.
Dr James Okello MBChB, MMed, PhD
Mental Health Department, Faculty of Medicine, Gulu University, Gulu, Uganda.
Best approaches to management of traumas and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in victims of a conflict which occurred more than 14 years ago have become the focus of attention in today’s Uganda of 2020. Most programs have focused on resilience, posttraumatic growth, transitional justice and peace-building processes as well as psychotherapeutic and psycho-educational interventions. Treatment, however, must be individualized and the victim and their family’s explanatory model for the trauma are key in help-seeking, reparation and determining one’s best approach(es) to the treatment. Most work on trauma in victims of armed conflict has a reverse focus; looking at areas of vulnerability rather than strengths or resilience. Beyond the assessment and documentation of traumas and PTSD, (which is in and of itself potentially therapeutic through narrative exposure), a useful first step in management of delayed or prolonged trauma and PTSD is providing mental health sensitization to the families and psycho-education to the victims. This paper will focus itself on approaches to treatment for victims of post-traumatic stress disorder in post-conflict communities in Northern Uganda for traumas which happened decades ago.
- About The African Journal Of Traumatic Stress
- About CLAMP Refugees, Uganda Project (CLAMP- RU)
- EDITORIAL: Well-Being And The Traumatic COVID-19 Pandemic
- Major Depressive Disorder And Associated Factors Among Adult Refugees Attending A Refugee Center, In Kampala, Uganda
- Sexual And Gender-Based Violence And Torture Experiences Of South Sudanese Refugees In Northern Uganda: Health And Justice Responses
- Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder Among HIV- Infected Adults Attending An HIV Treatment Clinic In Post-Conflict Gulu District, Uganda
- Preventing Suicide Behavior Using Village Helpers In Post-Conflict Northern Uganda
INTRODUCTIONNot everyone who experiences trauma requires treatment. Some recover with the help of family, friends, clergy or tradition. But many do need professional treatment to recover from the psychological damage that can result from experiencing, witnessing, or participating in an overwhelmingly traumatic event or events. A number of direct and indirect mental health and psychosocial interventions to address the potentially long-lasting consequences of victimization exist, but most are not specific to PTSD. Most programs have focused on resilience building, transitional justice and peace-building processes as well as psychotherapeutic and psycho-educational interventions. We focus, here, on what works in the northern Ugandan context and approaches in Uganda. Although a majority of the population living in conflict-affected areas will experience or has experienced a severe trauma at some point, the fraction of those who develop lasting psychiatric disorder reactions is in fact relatively small. There is evidence that psychotherapies work in the northern Ugandan context although not specific to PTSD (Nakimuli-Mpungu et al, 2013; Mutamba et al., 2018). So a principle treatment modality for PTSD would be some type of psychotherapy, such as supportive psychotherapy, narrative exposure, or interpersonal and counseling therapies that have shown promise in the Ugandan context, with medication used to augment the psychotherapy and help reduce symptoms. Best approaches focus on three goals of treatment:
- To help patients regain a sense of being worthwhile;
- To help patients again feel in control of themselves and their lives;
- To help patients re-work their shattered assumptions.
A PHASED APPROACH TO TREATMENTWhile there are differences across disciplines and professional expertise in trauma treatment, in keeping with established research, such as work by Herman (1992), Van Der Kolk (1996), and others, our experience is that a phase-oriented model should be used to conceptualize group or individual treatment approaches that work in the Ugandan context. Best practices would have three phases:
- Phase I: Establishing safety, stabilization, symptom reduction and the therapeutic alliance
- Phase II: Dealing with the traumatic event; e.g., through remembering and abreaction, desensitization, deconditioning, mourning, etc.
- Phase III: Restructuring personal schema and integrating the trauma into a meaningful life narrative; i.e., putting the trauma into perspective and moving forward in developing a positive life.
ResilienceMost work on trauma and negative life events in victims of armed conflict have a reverse focus, looking at areas of vulnerability rather than strengths or resilience- the ability to maintain a state of normal equilibrium in the presence of extremely unfavorable circumstances. Building resilience is a vital next step for those who need it, with factors such positive beliefs, attitudes, coping strategies, behaviours and good psychosocial support important in promoting resilience among victims. Whether it can be said that one has resilience depends on one’s perception: does one conceptualize an event as traumatic or, or as an opportunity to learn and grow? Although it is possible to normalize the symptoms of trauma as an understandable reaction to the experience through sensitization or psycho-education, resilience building seeks to emphasize that events are not traumatic until we experience them as traumatic. The theory is that every frightening event, no matter how negative it might seem, has the potential to be traumatic or not to the person experiencing it, hence the term potentially traumatic events (PTE) .The experience isn’t inherent in the event; it resides in how one interprets or constructs it psychologically. It is important to note that resilience building or positive construal of one’s traumatic experiences can be taught as a set of skills, to reframe them in positive terms when the default response is emotionally distressing, to better regulate their emotions.
MANAGING TRAUMA AND DELAYED PTSDRegarding the management of trauma and delayed PTSD as its associated features, we acknowledge that a significant number of victims are very resilient. However, mental health literacy and skills are often lacking for both the victims as well as their helping professionals. Beyond the assessment and documentation of traumas and PTSD, which is in and of itself potentially therapeutic, a useful first step in management of delayed or prolonged trauma and PTSD is providing mental health sensitization to the families and psycho-education to the victims. The aim, here, is to ensure an identity shift from victim to survivor to thriver. A key focus of attention is making the link between the experiences and reactions to the traumatic events and then to ‘normalize’ the reactions. In cases of prolonged trauma and/or PTSD, the principal reasons for using medications to treat PTSD (if needed) are: Reduce PTSD specific symptoms:
- Frequency and/or severity of intrusive symptoms,
- Interpreting incoming stimuli as recurrences of the trauma,
- Developing hyperarousal to stimuli reminiscent of the trauma, & generalized hyperarousal,
- Becoming avoidant, Developing numbing)
- Treat depression and/or mood swings
- Treat anxiety and sleep disturbences
- Reduce psychotic or dissociative symptoms
- Reduce impulsivity and aggression against self and others.
Goals of early-stage treatment include:
- Helping patients improve self-care. As children or young abductees, these victims were often forced into positions of taking care of an adult’s needs, and did not receive appropriate care themselves. Thus, they did not learn to take care of themselves.
- Establishing a better sense of safety by helping them to reduce the suicidal ideations and behaviors as well as other self-destructive and self-defeating coping strategies.
- Reducing symptoms of PTSD, dissociation, anxiety, disrupted sleep and depression. Here, medications may be very helpful.
- Acknowledging that trauma played a central role in the development of their current symptomatology and dysfunction. Education about their disorder and its treatment is essential.
- Improving functioning in their everyday life, such as at work and play, in school, and in relationships.
- Teaching, training, and helping them to practice better coping mechanisms to assist them in managing their PTSD and dissociative symptoms.
- Helping them to improve their relationships and shore up their support systems.
Goals of mid-stage treatment include:
- Talking about the traumas: This is if the patient is able to put words to the traumatic experiences. This involves understanding the meaning of what happened and correcting cognitive distortions as more important than the veracity of the memories per se. For instance, being forced to hurt others by the LRA may mean to the victim, “I was to blame for doing it,” “I am bad,” “I am not forgive-able,” etc. The victim needs to construct as integrated a memory as possible of what happened to them and what it meant in reality, while experiencing the associated feelings. He or she needs to realize that the traumas happened a long time ago, were survived, and are not happening now. Victims need to realize that their mistreatment by their captors was not their (victims’) fault. They need to put into perspective that the traumas did not destroy their self-worth.
- Bearing the pain: Through the relationship with the therapist, victims need to learn that they must and can bear the associated pain. It is only through the controlled and coordinated experiencing of these intense trauma-related affects that the victims can decrease the intensity of their fear and pain. The therapist then helps the patient to find words to describe these experiences and to make meaning out of them. Nonverbal techniques can be very helpful to patients who can describe their traumas in words.
- Relationship with the therapist: Having a secure, trusting and safe relationship with a therapist. It is only through the relationship with the therapist that the victim can face memories in a controlled and coordinated manner.
- Reality re-orientation: Reassessing former understanding of how the real world operates. Before therapy, the patient’s perceptions were fraught with misconceptions and distortions about themselves and the world. This can include issues regarding identity, competence, trust, power and control, autonomy, and value systems.
Goals of late-stage treatment include:
- New Self: To coalesce a new sense of self based on the patient’s real strengths and weaknesses.
- Forgiveness: To forgive, let go of, and grieve the past. The patient will never have the parents or the childhood that was wanted, and for this they must grieve.
- Relationships: To make and maintain new healthier relationships.
- Termination: To finally terminate therapy and grieve the loss of the therapist.
CONCLUSIONIn sum, there is a paucity of data regarding best approaches and treatment facilities for the LRA traumas and delayed PTSD in northern Uganda. The most feasible approaches would require, at the barest minimum, a public-private partnership with the Ministries of health and local government health facilities to ensure continued access to and utilization of an established trauma mental health service as well as a sustainable referral system (Nakimuli et al, 2013). Community based group rather than individual approaches to treatment are imperative to help bridge the human resource gaps as well as providing the much needed social capital to help victims improve their livelihoods. This can all be engulfed in the proposed and well tried out Group Support Psychotherapy (GSP) approach (Nakimuli et al, 2015)
- Chu JA: Rebuilding Shattered Lives: The Responsible Treatment of Complex Posttraumatic and Dissociative Disorders. New York, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1998.
- Herman JL: Trauma and Recovery. New York, Harper-Collins, 1992.
- Okello, J., Onen, T.S. & Musisi, S. (2007). Psychiatric disorders among war abducted and non-abducted adolescents in Gulu district, Uganda: A comparative study. African Journal of Psychiatry; 10, 225-231.
- Eth S, Pynoos RS: Developmental perspective on psychic trauma in childhood. In Figley CR (ed): Trauma and Its Wake, Volume I. New York, Brunner/Mazel, 1985.
- Janoff-Bulman R: The aftermath of victimization: Rebuilding shattered assumptions. In Figley CR (ed): Trauma and Its Wake, Volume I. New York, Brunner/Mazel, 1985.
- van der Kolk BA, McFarlane AC, Weisaeth L (eds): Traumatic Stress: The Effects of Overwhelming Experience on Mind, Body, and Society. New York, The Guilford Press, 1996.
- Klasen, F., Gherke, J., Metzner, F., Okello, J.(2013). Complex Trauma Symptoms in Former Ugandan Child Soldiers. Journal of Aggression, Maltreatment, and Trauma 22, 698-713.
- Nakimuli-Mpungu E, Alderman, S, Kinyanda E, Allden K, Pavia A, Betancourt T, Okello J,Nakku J, Adaku A, Musisi S.A (2013) Implementation and Scale-Up of Psycho-Trauma Centers in a Post-Conflict Area: A Case Study of a Private–Public Partnership in Northern Uganda. PLoS Med10(4):e1001427. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1001427
- Okello J, Nakimuli-Mpungu E, Musisi S, Broekaert E & Derluyn I.(2014). The Association between Attachment and Mental Health Symptoms among School-going Adolescents in Northern Uganda: the Moderating Role of War-related Trauma. Plos One 9(3):e88494
- Klasen F, Reissmann S, Voss C, Okello J (2014)The Guiltless Guilty – Trauma-related Guilt and Psychopathology in former Ugandan Child Soldiers” .Child Psychiatry & Human Development.05/2014.
- James Okello, Maarten De Schryver, Seggane Musisi, Eric Broekaert, Ilse Derluyn(2014) Differential roles of childhood adversities and stressful war experiences in the development of mental health symptoms in post-war adolescents in northern Uganda. BMC Psychiatry 09/2014; 14(1):260.
- The role of shame in posttraumatic stress disorder: A proposal for a socio-emotional model for DSM-V Ashwin Budden
- Nakimuli-Mpungu E, Wamala K, Okello J, Alderman S, Odokonyero R, Musisi S et al (2015):Group Support Psychotherapy For Depression Treatment In People With HIV/AIDS In Northern Uganda: A Single-Centre Randomized Controlled Trial. The Lancet HIV-D-14-00105r2 0069 S2352-3018(15)00041-7
- Mutamba BB, Kohrt BA, Okello J, Nakigudde J, Opar B, Musisi S et al (2018): Contextualization of psychological treatments for government health systems in low-resource settings: group interpersonal psychotherapy for caregivers of children with nodding syndrome in Uganda. Implementation Science (2018) 13:90. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13012-018-0785-y